Updated 12/29/2023
The best conventional reels should be tough, corrosion resistant, smooth, and reliable to handle big fish. Conventional reels are used for everything from jigging to trolling to casting. Key considerations like star vs lever drag and level-winds are important for anglers to consider based on their preferred fishing method.
In this article, we take a look at the top conventional reels on the market, considering factors like price, performance, quality, and value.
Whether you are a beginner or an expert angler, these reels are sure to meet your needs and help land your next big catch!
*Disclosure: I only recommend products I would use myself and all opinions expressed here are my own. This post may contain affiliate links that at no additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission.
Our Top 7 Picks
- Best Conventional Reel Under $200: Penn Squall II Star Drag
- Best Conventional Reel Under $100: Shimano TR
- Best Budget Conventional Reel: KastKing Rover
- Best Conventional Reel for Jigging: Penn Squall II Level Wind Line Counter
- Best Conventional Reel for Trolling: Shimano Tekota Line Counter
- Best High Speed Conventional Reel: Daiwa Saltist
- Best Conventional Reel for Surf Fishing: Penn Fathom II Star Drag
The 7 Best Conventional Reels
Whether you’re a new angler or a grizzled expert, we have you covered. Check out our recommendations for best conventional reels, also known as round reels, by category like best budget, best for different price points, and best for trolling amongst others!
1. Penn Squall II Star Drag
- Gear Ratio: 6.1:1
- Max Drag: 20 to 25 lb
- Drag Type: Star Drag
- Line Counter: On select models
- Ball Bearings: 6+1
- Weight: 15.3 to 19.2 oz
Pros:
- 15CS model has premium casting features
- High quality for reasonable price
Our pick for the best conventional reel under $200 is the Penn Squall II Star Drag. This is a great, balanced reel that is built from high quality components, priced reasonably, and includes the right features for prudent surf or nearshore/offshore anglers.
It comes in 5 sizes, from 12 to 40. We recommend the 15CS for anglers that need the best casting control. The ‘CS’ model includes upgraded spool bearings and a knob mag dial that improve casting control.
This reel has a star drag which we recommend for targeting fish under 30 lbs because we like the versatility of the star drag and its slightly better casting capabilities. If focusing on castability, we recommend this version without a level-wind. See our recommendation for best jigging conventional reel for the best use-case for the level wind version of this reel.
2. Shimano TR
- Gear Ratio: 4.3:1
- Max Drag: 14 lb
- Drag Type: Star Drag
- Line Counter: No
- Bearings: 1
- Weight: 12.5 to 13.2
Pros:
- Budget friendly price
- Star drag & level wind combo great for beginners
Our pick for the best conventional reel under $100 is the Shimano TR conventional reel. This reel is a great budget entry point for saltwater, great lakes salmon, and catfish anglers that want a decent budget conventional reel for light trolling, jigging, or casting.
We like the combination of a level-wind and star drag on a budget reel. These features are a bit more beginner friendly because the level wind means the line automatically spools evenly and the star drag is versatile for small to medium sized fish.
The budget price point comes with considerations to balance. The reel body is graphite instead of metal which is slightly less robust. The 14 lb drag is low compared to the higher end reels on this list but can still handle moderately large fish.
3. KastKing Rover
- Gear Ratio: 3.6:1 to 5.3:1
- Max Drag: 15 to 30 lb
- Drag Type: Star Drag
- Line Counter: No
- Ball Bearings: 6+1 or 4+1
- Weight: 11.6 to 22.1 oz
Pros:
- Budget friendly price
- Star drag & level wind combo great for beginners
Our pick for the best budget conventional reel is the KastKing Rover. This reel surprised us with the number of premium features it has for the budget price point. The Rover has a full aluminum frame, aluminum spool, brass gears, and stainless steel worm gear.
The drag ratings from 15 to 30 lbs are competitive with higher end reels. We like the star drag and level wind combo for beginners because the level wind means the line automatically spools evenly and the star drag is versatile for small to medium sized fish.
This reel is a great budget entry point into conventional reels and would be a great choice for catfish, salmon, striped bass, and most inshore species. For larger offshore species we recommend bumping up price points.
4. Penn Squall II Level Wind Line Counter
- Gear Ratio: 4.9:1
- Max Drag: 33 lb
- Drag Type: Star Drag
- Line Counter: Available on select models
- Ball Bearings: 3+1
- Weight: 16.8 to 24.7 oz
Pros:
- Line counter & level wind great for jigging for medium-sized species
Our pick for the best conventional reel for jigging is the Penn Squall II Level Wind Line Counter conventional reel. This reel is a purpose-built, jigging machine. The lower gear ratio allows for incredible torque to reel in large fish. The high 33 lb max drag is robust and can handle almost most fish in the water.
We recommend the level wind, line counter version of this reel as a premium jigging conventional reel for medium sized fish because it has all the best features needed in a jigging reel. This is a great setup for bull reds, flounder, pompano, snapper, and smaller grouper.
For targeting the most massive species, like big sharks or grouper, think about going with a reel with a lever drag and no level wind. Big fish can pull so hard they bind the level wind mechanism and a lever drag is generally preferred in those situations.
5. Shimano Tekota Line Counter
- Gear Ratio: 3.9:1 or 6.3:1
- Max Drag: 24 to 35 lb
- Drag Type: Star Drag
- Line Counter: Available on select models
- Ball Bearings: 3+1 or 4+1
- Weight: 15.5 to 30.7
Pros:
- Perfect trolling reel features
Our pick for the best conventional trolling reel is the Shimano Tekota Line Counter. This is a perfect reel for trolling setups targeting salmon, striper, kingfish, wahoo, mahi, and tuna. The line counter is excellent for conveniently getting baits to the proper depths.
The reel features Shimano’s CoreProtect for increased corrosion resistance and an oversized ergonomic handle to easily grip while reeling in big fish. The reel has a loud clicker which is great for detecting strikes while trolling.
This reel is built from high quality components and is an awesome choice for a conventional trolling reel.
Check out our article on the best trolling reels for additional reading.
6. Daiwa Saltist
- Gear Ratio: 6.4:1
- Max Drag: 17.6 to 22 lb
- Drag Type: Star Drag
- Line Counter: No
- Ball Bearings: 4+1
- Weight: 15.2 to 21.2 oz
Pros:
- Reliable highly corrosion resistant
Our pick for the best high speed conventional reel is the Daiwa Saltist. This reel features an anodized aluminum frame and blistering fast (for a conventional reel) 6.4:1 gear ratio. This is a great choice for retrieving high speed metal spoons for mackerel or tuna.
The real has a round EVA foam handle that’s easy to grip. The max drag is 17.6 or 22 lbs depending on the model which is plenty for the medium large fish you’d target with a fast gear ratio rod.
7. Penn Fathom II Conventional Reel
- Gear Ratio: 4.8:1 to 6.1:1
- Max Drag: 30 pound
- Drag Type: Star Drag
- Line Counter: Available on select models
- Ball Bearings: 6
- Weight: 16.2 to 20.7 oz
Pros:
- Heavy duty
- High quality
Our pick for the best conventional reel for surf fishing is the Penn Fathom II Conventional Reel. This reel is super smooth and has a beefy 30 pound drag that is perfect for dealing with larger saltwater fish. This is a great option for anglers looking for a mix of inshore, surf, and offshore fishing. We prefer the version that does not have a level wind because this allows for anglers to maximize casting distance while surf fishing.
We’re always looking for high quality equipment at a value price point, and the Fathom II delivers. The Fathom II has a full metal body/sideplates, a 6 shielded stainless steel ball bearing system, anti-reverse bearing, and star drag.
Check out our article on best surf fishing reels for additional surf fishing reel recommendations.
Reel Comparison Table
Check out our handy comparison table showing key specifications for our top reel choices.
| Reel Name | Gear Ratio | Max Drag | Drag Type | Line Counter | Ball Bearings | Weight (oz) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Penn Squall II Star Drag | 6.1:1 | 20 to 25 lb | Star Drag | On select models | 6+1 | 15.3 to 19.2 |
| Shimano TR | 4.3:1 | 14 lb | Star Drag | No | 1 | 12.5 to 13.2 |
| KastKing Rover | 3.6:1 to 5.3:1 | 15 to 30 lb | Star Drag | No | 6+1 or 4+1 | 11.6 to 22.1 |
| Penn Squall II Level Wind Line Counter | 4.9:1 | 33 lb | Star Drag | Available on select models | 3+1 | 16.8 to 24.7 |
| Shimano Tekota Line Counter | 3.9:1 or 6.3:1 | 24 to 35 lb | Star Drag | Available on select models | 3+1 or 4+1 | 15.5 to 30.7 |
| Daiwa Saltist | 6.4:1 | 17.6 to 22 lb | Star Drag | No | 4+1 | 15.2 to 21.2 |
| Penn Fathom II Conventional Reel | 4.8:1 to 6.1:1 | 30 pound | Star Drag | Available on select models | 6 | 16.2 to 20.7 |
Conclusion
In conclusion, having the right conventional reel is essential for a successful day fishing. There are many great options available, but the Penn Squall II Star Drag and Penn Fathom II Star Drag stand out as our favorites. These reels offer a balance of performance, durability, and value that make them solid choices for conventional reel anglers.
Check out our articles for great rods to pair with these reels:
- Best Trolling Rods
- Best Saltwater Fishing Rods
- Best Mahi Mahi Rods
- Best Saltwater Rod & Reel Combos
- Best Inshore Fishing Rods
- Best Surf Fishing Rods
- Best Pier Fishing Rods
Check out our related reel articles:
Buying Guide – How to Choose The Best Conventional Reel For You
Key factors for choosing the best conventional reel include reel size, drag type, line counter or not, level wind or not, build/material quality, and smoothness. Additionally, preferred fishing technique like deep-water offshore fishing vs surf fishing can significantly affect reel choice.
Line Capacity
Line capacity refers to how much fishing line fits on the reel. The total spool capacity is specified by mono vs braid and line strength as pound test. An example line capacity would be “200 yards of 20-pound test braid”.
Braid is smaller diameter than mono at the same line strength which means you can fit more braid on a reel. Also, higher pound test line is larger diameter and will take up more space on the reel spool.
Line capacity is usually less of a determining factor for conventional reels. Applications like trolling, surf fishing, and jigging in deep water can require tons of line. It’s common for conventional reels to be able to hold 300 yards or more of heavy-duty line.
Ball Bearings
Ball bearings in fishing reels are small, spherical bearings that reduce friction and increase smoothness of a reel’s operation. They are located within the internal mechanism of the reel and allow the reel’s moving parts to rotate smoothly against each other.
Most quality reels have at least four ball bearings. More ball bearings is usually better because the higher the number of ball bearings, the more friction is reduced and less wear and tear on the internal reel components. That said, ball bearing quality and material choice is also important. I would rather have four high-quality ball bearings than ten low quality bearings.
Most ball bearings are stainless steel but can also be ceramic. Many reels list something like “5+1 bearings” – this reel would be five ball bearings plus one roller bearing.
Drag System
Drag systems on fishing reels provide resistance to the spool as line is retrieved. A loose drag makes it easier for the spool to spin freely and a tight drag makes it difficult to rotate the spool.
Drag systems work using a series of washers or disks pressed together by a drag knob or level (usually on the top of spinning reels). As the drag is tightened, the drag washers are pressed together which increases resistance on the spool. Drag should be set to match the strength and size of the target fish species.
Setting the drag properly is an art. You want the drag tight enough to reel in the fish, but not too tight to where a strong pull could snap your line or cause your fishing knot to fail. When the drag is properly set, a strong pull from a fish should be able to pull some line from your reel.
A drag rating around 10 pounds is plenty for most inshore applications. For targeting larger fish or offshore, think of upsizing to 20 or 30 pound drag rated reels.
The two popular types of drag for conventional reels are lever drag and star drag.
Lever Drag
Lever drag reels use a lever on the side of the reel to the drag. These reels have preset drag positions that usually include free spool, bait, strike, and max settings but also allow for micro adjustments to really dial-in the drag. Lever drags are best used when targeting the largest fish, 30 lbs or larger, because drag settings can quickly be set for each phase of the catch. The common wisdom is the strike drag setting should be one third of the strength of the line. For example, 60-lb line should have a 20 lb strike setting.
Star Drag
Star drag reels can be identified by the star-shaped drag adjustment wheel just inside of the handle. They allow for on-they-fly adjustment and are a good option when it’s possible to hook into a variety of fish sizes that require different drag settings. Star drag reels are considered to cast slightly better than lever drags, but that’s usually not a big issue on high-quality reels. If targeting smaller fish, under 30 lbs, with a conventional reel, we recommend leaning towards a star drag. One downside of star drag reels is you can’t tell what the drag setting is just by glancing at the reel like you can with lever drag.
Gear Ratio
The gear ratio on a fishing reel refers to the relationship between the number of turns on the spool for every turn of the handle. For example, a gear ratio of 5:1 means the spool rotates five times for every turn of the handle.
Gear ratio is an important consideration when selecting a fishing reel because it affects the speed at which you can retrieve your line. A higher gear ratio is better for situations where you need to reel long distances or require fast bait presentations. A lower gear ratio is preferred for situations where a lower retrieval rate is desired, like when using finesse techniques.
Most reels have a gear ratio between 4:1 to 9.2:1. Conventional reels tend to have slower gear ratios that allow for more torque and force to reel in huge fish. Between 4 and 6 to 1 are common gear ratios for conventional reels.
Level Wind
A level wind conventional reel is a reel that has a mechanism that evenly distributes line on the spool as the angler reels in. Most low-profile baitcasting reels having a built-in level wind system. Conventional reels can come with or without.
Level wind reels have pros and cons. The advantages of having a level wind reel is they are easier for beginners because the angler doesn’t have to manually distribute the line on the reel. The cons are, level wind systems can bind when reeling in massive fish and tend to have shorter casting distances than their non-level wind counterparts because of the friction caused through the level-wind mechanism. Also, when casting long rods like 10-15′ surf rods, the best practice is to “bundle” line evenly on the reel because it will come off the spool smoother when high-speed casts quickly rip line off the reel. Birds nests also tend to be worse on level wind reels than on non-level wind reels.
Line Counters
Many conventional reels come with built-in line counters. Line counters allow the angler to precisely determine how much line has been paid out the spool which helps accurately set depths for both trolling and jigging. Anglers that need precise depth control should think about getting a conventional reel with a line counter.
Material Quality
Material quality is an important consideration for picking a conventional reel. Fishing reels are typically made of a combination of metal, rubber, and plastic parts. The body of the reel is usually made of aluminum or another type of metal to provide strength and durability. Plastic is used for many of the peripheral parts like the handle or drag knob because it is lightweight and corrosion-resistant.
Rubber seals may be used to protect against water, dirt, and sand ingress. High-end reels may have ceramic bearings or higher quality metal components.
Look for reels made of high-quality materials with solid, durable construction. Conventional reels tend to be predominately metal because of their higher strength requirements to reel in huge fish.
Reel Brakes
Conventional reels have reel brakes. When you make a cast with a conventional reel, the momentum of the bait pulls line off of the spool. The spool rotates fastest at the beginning of the cast when forces are the highest. The reel brake slows down rotation of the spool to keep the fishing line tight on the spool and stop a backlash mess.
Brakes are important because if the spool rotates faster than the speed your bait is pulling out line, your reel will become a huge backlash mess.
There are three main types of brakes on fishing reels: centrifugal brakes, magnetic brakes, and digitally controlled brakes.
Centrifugal Brakes
Centrifugal brakes work by using a series of small weights that are pushed outward by centrifugal forces when the spool begins to spin. This increases resistance on the spool. To adjust centrifugal brakes, the side plate must be removed.
Magnetic Brakes
Magnetic brakes work by using a series of magnets to create resistance on the spool. They are considered more precise and higher quality than centrifugal brakes. Magnetic brakes are adjusted by a small dial on the side of the reel and can be fine tuned to adjust the resistance that is applied to the spool.
Digitally Controlled Brakes
Digitally controlled braking system utilize a microcomputer to monitor spool speed. The computer automatically applies the perfect amount of brake at superhuman speeds to prevent backlash. Digitally controlled brakes all but remove the ability for the reel to backlash.
Conventional Reel Frequently Asked Questions
What size conventional reel is best?
Anglers should match their conventional reel size to their target fish species and their preferred fishing technique. Inshore anglers targeting smaller fish like redfish and stripers can get away with smaller size reels. Offshore anglers targeting massive fish like sharks, tuna, or marlin should get a larger reel. Larger reels can fit more line and larger diameter line.
What rod to pair with conventional reel?
Conventional reels should be paired with high quality casting rods chosen for their specific fishing technique. Surf anglers using conventional reels should match their reels with a 10-15′ surf casting rod. Boat anglers targeting huge fish should match their reel to a 5-7′ heavy-duty jigging or trolling rod.
How do you care for conventional reels?
Caring for conventional reels is important to ensure they perform their best and last a long time. Here are a few tips to take care of your reel:
- Rinse the reel with freshwater after each use to remove any salt, sand, or dirt
- Periodically lubricate the moving parts
- Store the reel properly in a dry protected place when not in use
What strength fishing line for conventional reels?
Conventional reels can use a wide range of fishing line strengths. 20 lb braid is a great all-around option for inshore fishing. Boat anglers targeting huge species should use 60-80 lb braid. Be sure to match the strength of the line to the size of the target fish.
Is mono or braid better for conventional reels?
Braided fishing line is preferable for conventional reels. Braided line has significantly smaller diameter for the same strength line when compared to mono. This can be key for all kinds of fishing, because wind and current will constantly be pulling at your line. The smaller diameter means less effect from the elements. Additionally, you can fit more braided line than mono on the reel spool.
How to prevent backlash on conventional reel?
There are four keys to minimizing backlash on conventional reels:
- Set the spool tension knob properly. The spool should be loose enough that the weight of the bait will freely pull line in air. When the bait hits the water, the tension knob should be set so the bait stops pulling line.
- Don’t overdo it with casting power. Trying to whip the bait as hard and as far as possible will increase the likelihood of a backlash.
- Be careful casting light baits into the wind. Strong headwind or crosswind increases likelihood of backlashes
- Use your thumb to moderate the reel speed during the cast
How to switch reel from right to left handed?
Unlike most spinning reels, conventional reels are not designed to switch from right to left handed and vice-versa. Conventional reels are ordered either right or left handed from the manufacturer.
Low profile baitcasting reel vs conventional reel
When anglers think of baitcasting reels, they usually think of low profile reels. These are versatile, compact reels that are perfect for repeated casts on a long day fishing.
Baitcasting reels also include what are called conventional reels, or round reels, that are rounder in shape and used more for huge baits and trolling in either saltwater or larger lake fishing. Conventional reels are heavier duty and generally have much higher drag and line capacities than low profile baitcasting reels.
Written By: Andrew Juran
Andrew is a seasoned angler with over 25 years of experience fishing across the United States. He has caught hundreds of fish using various techniques and mentored many in the art of fishing. An advocate for sustainable fishing, Andrew is an active member of the Coastal Conservation Association, an organization committed to marine conservation.
For frequent fishing tips, behind-the-scenes looks, and real-time catches, connect with Andrew on Instagram
